The incidence of malignant melanoma is increasing by 4% per year; nearly 8500 people will die from this disease in 2008. Atypical moles may increase the risk of melanoma.
Atypical moles—also known as atypical nevi, dysplastic nevi, Clark nevi, and familial atypical nevi—were first described in 1978, when their association with malignant melanoma was recognized. These distinctive skin lesions were noted in 37 of 58 members in six families with histories of melanoma. (“The B-K mole syndrome,” Arch Dermatol. 1978;114(5):732-738)
While a single atypical mole does not increase one’s lifetime risk of malignant melanoma, these lesions are markers for melanoma, and they are sometimes difficult to distinguish from malignant lesions.
When multiple atypical moles are present, the risk for developing melanoma is increased—the greatest risk being in individuals who have more than 50 atypical moles and who have two or more family members with melanoma.
Atypical moles are considered by some to be precursors of malignant melanoma. However, most melanomas (80%) arise on normal skin, and most atypical moles do not progress to malignant melanoma. Thus, the presence of multiple atypical moles simply serves as a signal of increased risk; only those atypical moles that are worrisome for melanoma or that are changing need to be removed.
Features of Atypical Moles
Age at onset: After six to 12 months of age; usually present by 20 years of age
Location: Any site; can be in sun-protected areas. Back is usually most heavily involved
Number: One to several hundred
Size: No lower size limit; usually over 6 mm in diameter (the diameter of a pencil eraser)
Color: Multiple shades of brown, dappled or variegated, dark pigmentation
Shape: Round, oval, or asymmetric
Border: Irregular or poorly demarcated; may have darker, raised center with lighter surrounding component (“fried-egg”)
Surface: Usually raised and/or textured
Features of Normal Moles
Age at onset: After six to 12 months of age; usually present by 20 years of age
Location: Any site, but sun-protected areas usually have fewer
Number: Few to several hundred
Size: Mostly less than 6 mm in diameter
Color: Typically uniform; no more than two shades of brown; usually lighter in pigmentation
Shape: Round or oval
Border: Smooth, regular; distinct edges
Surface: Uniform; may be raised, but usually smooth
Features of Malignant Melanoma
Age at onset: Usually adulthood, except in children with giant congenital moles or atypical mole syndrome
Location: In men, mostly on trunk; in women, most often on lower extremities; can occur in any location, however, including mucous membranes
Number: One, but may occur at more than one site over time
Size: Can be any size
Color: Variable, from light (as in amelanotic melanoma) to blue, brown, or black. Colors change over time. Usually multiple shades in one lesion
Shape: Asymmetric and irregular, though nodular (round) melanomas occur
Border: Usually irregular, with indistinct portions, except in some nodular melanomas
(Am Fam Physician. 2008;78(6):735-740, and National Cancer Institute Information Resources)
The incidence of malignant melanoma—the deadliest form of skin cancer—is increasing faster than any other malignancy. Individuals with multiple atypical moles are at higher risk. However, all people should limit their exposure to sunlight, which is clearly associated with melanoma. Anyone with an unusual-appearing mole, or one that is changing in any way, should seek professional medical evaluation.
The copyright of the article Atypical Moles in Skin Disease is owned by Stephen Allen Christensen. Permission to republish Atypical Moles in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.
Thank you for not putting a "size" on Melanoma. Most articles say
they are larger than a pencil eraser, etc, but that is falsely reassuring.
Just a side note, but lesions on palms/soles and the groin area are more
likely to be atypical nevi or melanoma.
Dec 15, 2008 12:39 PM
Guest :
Stick to non derms things doc. Clark's nevi are NOT a precursor to
melanoma. The literature is contradictory and no definitive evidence has
been cited to establish anything beyond an anecdotal or coincidental
association between nevi and melanoma, other than congenital nevi, which
have nothing to do 'atypical' nevi.
Dec 15, 2008 1:40 PM
Stephen Allen Christensen :
I may have been unclear about the association of Clark's nevi (also called
atypical moles, atypical nevi, etc., as stated in the article) with
malignant melanoma. While a single Clark's nevus doesn't increase one's
lifetime risk of melanoma, the presence of multiple such lesions is clearly
associated with an increased risk of malignancy. Clark's nevi are markers
for melanoma, meaning a person with Clark's nevi should be carefully
observed for the development of a melanoma. As I mentioned in paragraph 4,
most Clark's lesions don't become melanomas; the latter usually arise de
novo on normal skin. Clark's nevi only need to be addressed if they develop
worrisome features. As a rural doc with no dermatologists nearby, I
discovered (and excised) three malignant melanomas on two patients whom I
had followed for several years BECAUSE they had multiple Clark's nevi. The
patients were referred to the 'big city' for definitive management, and
both of them, as far as I know, are alive today.